Investment Trends Survey

Benchmark Properties

Contributors to our quarterly survey are asked to provide an opinion on a wide range of questions related to investment performance trends and valuation parameters. To ensure consistent and valuable results, we have developed a list of definitions for each of the asset types included in the survey. Additionally, for each of the markets covered in the survey we have chosen a property which fits the appropriate definition. These benchmark definitions and the representative properties are evaluated on a regular basis, and where appropriate, changes are made.

Downtown Class “AA” Office
  • 400,000 to 900,000 square feet
  • Class “AA” physical features
  • Strong location in local market
  • 5% existing vacancy
  • 10% roll-over per year
  • Leased at market rates to good covenant tenants
Downtown Class “AA” Leasehold
  • Un-expired ground lease term of 80 years
  • No participation ground rent
  • No option to acquire the leased fee interest
  • Current rent is fixed for the next five years
  • The subsequent renewals are for ten year terms
  • The renewal rent is based on the market value of the land unimproved, multiplied by the market rate of return
Downtown Class “B” Office
  • 100,000 to 200,000 square feet
  • Class “B” physical features
  • Limited on-site parking
  • Good location
  • Multi-tenant
  • 5% vacant
  • 10% roll-over per year
  • Leased at market rates.
  • No triple “A” tenants
Downtown Office Land Parcel
  • 100% location in local market
  • One acre (209’ x 209’)
  • Has two major and one minor street frontage
  • Has zoning in place for 525,000 square feet of commercial density or 12.0 times coverage
Suburban Class “A” Office
  • 100,000 - 170,000 square feet
  • Class “A” physical features -5 to 10 years old
  • 3.0 stalls per 1,000 square feet surface parking
  • Prominent position within established and well recognized suburban business park
  • Multi tenant
  • 5% vacancy
  • 10% roll-over per year
  • Leased at market rates to good covenant tenants
Suburban ‘B’ Office
  • 100,000 - 170,000 s.f.
  • Class "B" physical features
  • 3.0 stalls per 1,000 s.f. surface parking
  • Prominent position within established and well recognized suburban business park
  • 5% vacancy
  • 10% roll-over per year
  • Leased at market rates to good covenant tenants
Suburban Land Parcel
  • Prominent position within an established and well recognized suburban business park
  • Primary access to the Park is vehicular as opposed to subway or LRT
  • 5 acres (square)
  • Two street frontages as well as Highway frontage
  • Zoned for one times coverage (i.e. 220,000 square feet) of commercial office
Montreal Midtown Class ‘A’ Office
  • 80,000 to 120,000 square feet
  • 10 to 15 years old
  • Class “A” physical features
  • Combination of indoor/outdoor parking; 1 to 2 stalls per 1,000 square feet
  • Location on a main road
  • Montreal Urban Community location, outside downtown but within 10 km from Place Ville-Marie
  • Multi-tenant
  • 5% vacancy
  • 10% annual rollover
  • Leased at market rates to good covenant tenants
Tier I Regional Mall
  • Greater than 700,000 square feet
  • Dominant market presence
  • Renovated in the past 5 years
  • 2/3 anchor tenants occupy 50% of rentable area
  • Expansion potential not to be considered
  • CRU sales have been growing and currently average >$450 per square feet sourced from 85% national tenants
Tier II Regional Mall
  • 400,000 s.f. - 600,000 s.f.
  • Dominant only in a local sense
  • Renovated in the past 10 years
  • 2 anchor tenants occupy at least 40% of rentable area
  • CRU sales are relatively flat and are < $400 per s.f.
  • Expansion potential not to be considered
Power Centre
  • Dominant for the region
  • Greater than 500,000 square feet
  • 5 to 10 years old
  • Major arterial position
  • Proximity to controlled highway access
  • Strong covenant, national tenants
  • 10-15 year leases
Food Anchored Retail Strip
  • 10 to 15 years old
  • 75,000 to 125,000 square feet
  • Intersection of two arterials
  • Secure local position
  • Mature residential district
  • Major chain supermarket of 45,000 square. ft. trading at $475 per square feet with 10 year lease
  • CRU mix contains blend of national / regional chains and local / independents
Enclosed Community Mall
  • 20 years old
  • 150,000 to 250,000 square feet enclosed
  • Intersection of two major arterials
  • Mix of national chains and local independents
  • Anchored by one major chain supermarket and at least one department / discount store
  • Typically of older construction, lying in mature area
Single Tenant Retail building
  • Greater than 80,000 square feet
  • Of recent vintage (+/-5 years old)
  • Suburban location, prominent arterial position
  • 25% site coverage with good parking (minimum 5.0 per 1,000 s.f.)
  • 15-year lease
  • Years one to five at market with 13% contractual rental growth in years six and eleven
  • Investment grade covenant strength (e.g. Home Depot, RONA and Canadian Tire)
  • For the purpose of this survey, assume the locations mentioned in the following chart have the above mentioned leasing characteristics
Suburban Multiple Unit Residential building
  • 150 - 300 Suites - highrise
  • 25 years old
  • Well maintained with no deferred maintenance
  • Good suburban location
  • Good proximity to retail and transportation facilities
  • Stabilized rents with stabilized operating expenses
  • Average of 15-25% annual tenant turnover
  • 25% cash to first mortgage at current rates
Multiple Unit Residential Land Parcel
  • Downtown Core / Waterfront location
  • Good proximity subway / public transit
  • 100-150 units at an average gross area of 1,000 square feet per unit
  • Zoning in place
Multiple Unit Residential Leasehold
  • Benchmark multi-residential building
  • Un-expired ground lease term of 80 years
  • Current rent is fixed for the next 15 years
  • The subsequent renewals are for ten year terms
  • No additional participation ground rent
  • Institutional ownership of the fee
  • No option to acquire the leased fee interest
  • The renewal rent is based on the market value of the land unimproved, and unencumbered, multiplied by the market rate of return
Downtown Multiple Unit Residential building
  • 150 -300 Suites, high-rise
  • 25 years old
  • Well maintained with no deferred maintenance
  • Good downtown location
  • Good proximity to retail and transportation facilities
  • Market rents with stabilized operating expenses
  • Average of 15%-25% annual tenant turnover
  • 25% cash to first mortgage at current rates
  • For the purpose of this survey, assume the buildings / locations mentioned in the following chart have the above mentioned leasing characteristics
Montreal Midtown Multiple Unit Residential building
  • 200 -300 suites, high-rise
  • 25 years old
  • Well maintained with no deferred maintenance
  • Good midtown location
  • Montreal Urban Community location, outside downtown but within 10 km from Place Ville-Marie
  • Good proximity to retail and transportation
  • Stabilized rents and stabilized operating expenses
  • Few, if any rental board cases
  • Average 15% to 25% annual rollover
  • 25% cash to first mortgage at current rates
Single-tenant Industrial building
  • 100,000 s.f. single tenant warehouse property
  • Pre-cast construction with 10% office finish and 28 ft. clear height
  • Of recent vintage (+/-5 years old)
  • Suburban location, with good highway access
  • 45% site coverage with good turning radius and good parking
  • 10 to 15 shipping doors
  • 10 year lease
  • Years one to five at market with 15% contractual rental growth in year six
  • Investment grade covenant strength (i.e. Standard & Poor BBB or better)
  • For the purpose of this survey, assume the buildings / locations mentioned in the following chart have the above mentioned leasing characteristics
Multi-tenant Industrial building
  • 60 - 100,000 square feet with 15% to 25% office finish and 18 ft. clear height
  • Of recent vintage (+/-10 years old).
  • Unit size range from 3,000 to 8,000 with 15 to 25 tenants
  • Suburban location
  • 40% site coverage with good turning radius, one shipping door per demised unit and good parking
  • Year one contract rates at market with annual rental growth.
  • Mostly local covenants but may have some recognizable nationals
  • Full occupancy and no month to month tenancies
  • Lease rollover of about 20-30% per annum for the next three years
Industrial Land Parcel
  • Prominent position within an established and well recognized business park
  • Excellent highway access, but no exposure
  • 5 to 10 acres
  • Zoned industrial, but no outside storage permitted
  • Two street frontages
  • Good frontage to depth ration
  • Services available at site boundary
  • No rail access
Hotel Property
  • 300 Rooms
  • Prominent Downtown location
  • 15 years old
  • 4 star quality
  • Renovation program evident
  • Well maintained with no deferred maintenance
  • Flag such as Marriott or Sheraton
  • Full services and amenities such as Bar / Restaurant; recreation facilities -indoor pool etc,
  • Parking availability